Chinese Roast Pork on Garlic Bread was a sandwich made popular in the 1960s and 70s in the Catskills region of upstate New York.
Known as the Borscht Belt or “Jewish Alps” back in the day, towns in the Catskills would swell during the summer with resort and camp vacationers from New York City.
Meals at Catskills resorts were pretty regimented. Dinner was usually served between 4:30 and 6:30 and the Kosher menu was limited so if you didn’t like what was being served, you were out of luck. Also, after a good late night comedy routine, game of cards, or horse racing at the Monticello Raceway, folks got hungry-hungry for Chinese food!
During my summer vacations, I sometimes worked as the night shift line cook at the Holiday Inn restaurant and bar, and frequently made this satisfying Chinese BBQ Pork and Garlic Bread sandwich and the occasional shrimp with lobster sauce for those hungry late night patrons.
The Origin of the Chinese Roast Pork and Garlic Bread Sandwich
The rumor is that this famed roast pork sandwich (some called it the “RPG,” for “Roast Pork and Garlic”) started in a Chinese/Italian/American restaurant called Herbie’s in Loch Sheldrake, NY.
Herbie’s was frequented by nightclub entertainers and comedians who hung out for late night snacks and drinks after their Catskills resort performances.
The restaurant’s Chinese Roast Pork Sandwich became so popular, it was replicated by many local restaurants and later migrated to the city, appearing in restaurants, bars and delis in Brooklyn.
It’s very possible you’ve never heard of the RPG sandwich––even my daughters thought I was crazy when I told them about it! But then I showed them this article, where a Senior Critic at Eater wrote about his search for the fabled sandwich.
Where Could You Get Chinese Roast Pork on Garlic Bread?
Sadly, Herbie’s in Loch Sheldrake closed down long ago, so you can’t get the original roast pork sandwich. Many of the local restaurants who offered Chinese Roast Pork on Garlic bread have also closed down.
Everyone had their favorite place those days. The ones I personally remember were:
- Singer’s: A Chinese/American deli and restaurant located on Main Street in Liberty, NY. We recently found out that the owners’ son, Jeff Golder, frequently cooks our recipes here at The Woks of Life, and that his sister Debi also reads the blog! My father, See Kam Leung worked there in the 1960s.
- Holiday Inn Restaurant & Bar: Off exit 100 in Liberty, NY, I worked there in the 1970s and early 1980s with my stepfather, Mr. Yiu, as a kitchen man and line cook making Chinese and American food. He taught me everything about both Chinese and American cooking, and many of our recipes on the blog are the result of those lessons!
- The Triangle Diner: Located just across from the entrance to Grossinger’s Hotel and resort, it was a frequent stop for both diner food and Chinese food. I knew most of the Chinese chefs working there in the day––it was a small Chinese community!
What is Chinese Roast Pork?
You can’t use just any roast pork for this sandwich!
For an authentic a Cuban sandwich, you have to use Cuban-style roast pork, right?
For an authentic Chinese Roast Pork Sandwich, you have to use Chinese Roast Pork, or Char Siu. It’s best made fresh from scratch.
The good news is, it’s easy! It takes less than an hour to make (minus marinating time). Check out our Chinese BBQ roast pork recipe to see how we make it.
What Kind of Bread To Use
Crusty Italian bread is best. That’s what was used at the Holiday Inn, and I’m pretty sure they used Italian bread at Herbie’s also.
An alternative could be a hoagie or submarine roll, but whatever bread you use, it needs the fresh garlic and must be lightly toasted!
What to Serve with this Sandwich
To do it in the true Catskills style, serve a Kosher pickle with this sandwich along with Chinese hot mustard and duck sauce on the side.
The sweet and spicy combination of these two classic sauces really add variety to your sandwich.
We’re excited to share this retro Catskills regional recipe!
Chinese Roast Pork on Garlic Bread: Recipe Instructions
Slice the Chinese roast pork (char siu) into thin slices. We used to use a deli slicer back in the day at the restaurant, but you can do fine with a good chef’s knife.
Mixed the fresh mashed garlic (you can also use a garlic press) with the olive oil and salt.
Cut the Italian roll in half. If the roll is very thick, you may want to remove some of the soft bread inside. I have seen Bobby Flay do this on sandwich showdowns on his “Beat Bobby Flay” show, and he always wins!
Save the removed bread to be made into breadcrumbs, or to add to meatloaf or meatballs!
Spread the garlic and olive oil mixture evenly on one side of the bread and lightly toast it.
Spread 2 teaspoons butter (if using) on the other side of the bread and repeat with the other roll. You can use the garlic and oil spread on both sides if you do not want to use butter.
Lay the sliced pork on the sandwich.
Close the sandwich, cut on a diagonal, and plate with a Kosher dill pickle, Chinese hot mustard, and duck sauce on the side.
We hope you enjoyed this recipe and piece of food history! Do you remember the RPG in your youth? Questions about how to make the recipe? Let us know in the comments.
Chinese Roast Pork on Garlic Bread: A Retro Sandwich Recipe
Ingredients
- 1 pound sliced Chinese roast pork (char siu) (450g)
- 3 cloves garlic (mashed)
- 1 1/2 tablespoons olive oil
- 1/8 teaspoon salt (or to taste)
- 2 Italian or submarine rolls
- 4 teaspoons 20g softened butter (optional)
- 2 tablespoons Chinese hot mustard to serve
- 2 tablespoons Duck sauce to serve
Instructions
- Slice the Chinese roast pork (char siu) into thin slices.
- Mixed the fresh mashed garlic (you can also use a garlic press) with the olive oil and salt.
- Cut the Italian roll in half. If the roll is very thick, you may want to remove some of the soft bread inside. Spread the garlic and olive oil mixture evenly on one side of the bread and lightly toast it.
- Spread 2 teaspoons butter (if using) on the other side of the bread and repeat with the other roll. You can use the garlic and oil spread on both sides if you do not want to use butter.
- Lay the sliced pork on the sandwich, close it, cut on a diagonal, and plate with a Kosher dill pickle, Chinese hot mustard, and duck sauce on the side.
Tips & Notes:
nutrition facts
The best. Gilbert’s Diner in Fort Lauderdale serves this unique sandwich.
Hey Rhoda, love to hear the tradition of the RPG lives on in Fort Lauderdale!
This sandwich is available at the Liberty Diner in Liberty right now.
Thanks for sharing that Jack! I have not tried their RPG sandwich but I bet you can do better with your own homemade char siu ;-)
WHERE CAN I BUY CHINESE ROAST PORK ON GARLIC BREAD IN NYC
Hi Sheldon, That’s a good question and unfortunately, I don’t have an answer. I have not seen anything like it on any menu for years. At this point, it’s best to make fresh roast pork and make your own RPG using our recipes!
Memories of the Holiday Inn! My aunt and uncle, Florence and Herbie, ran the place for years. I raise a commemorative pu pu platter in their collective honor.
Hi Jim, good to hear from you and I’ll join you in raising the pupu plater! I have a lot of great memories and experiences at the Holiday Inn working with your aunt and uncle :)
While I love most all of your recipes, my first stop whenever cooking Asian, I was pleasantly surprised to find this number one on my first search. (I’m making egg rolls and will have so much char siu left over) Thank you so much as well for your always thoughtful commentary. I usually jump right to the recipe except when visiting your site.
Hi Felise, this is the best recipe for any leftover cha siu you have. Hope you love it!
You’re in the same position I’m in. How to use it all before I have to freeze . I have some New Orleans French bread that it will be perfect on.
Hi! This is so cool to see. I am a native of Liberty NY, and my dad worked as a bellhop at Grossinger’s in the late 1970s/early 1980s when he was in high school. I always grew up eating this sandwich (we’re of German descent, so roast pork was very common in our home), yet had no clue it actually had its origins in the Catskills until I decided to make it for my boyfriend! He was absolutely puzzled and had never heard of it.
Thanks for the recipe, and for the cool post with the great memories of the Triangle Diner, Holiday Inn, and all the places where it was hip and happening when the Catskills were in their heyday.
Hi Jessica, such a delight to hear from a fellow liberty native! Thanks so much for sharing your story and hope you enjoyed making the roast pork and the famous sandwich!
I don’t remember a Herbies but I do remember a Lefties which had a great roast pork on garlic bread.
Hi David, Definitely sounds like Lefties and also Herbies was before my time :) I’m sure both versions of their Chinese RPGs were delicious.
Ftom Monticello, born n raised, class of 63. Worked at the Lantern , had my first RPG there in the early 60s
Awesome Jerome, the Lantern restaurant definitely had some history. I think my stepfather worked there in the 80s relieving a chef friend while he was recuperating from a car accident. RPG sandwiches were all the rage back then!
Great recipe
Thanks Barbara!
whoops! this is the dish posted in this past nyt sunday magazine by sam sifton, not the char siu recipe i posted. nice to know, no doubt for us wol fans, how ahead of the curve you are.
thanks,
a devoted fan
ps i hope to be able to make cha siu bao for our menu to celebrate lunar new year. gung hey fat choy!
Hi essell, just read that article yesterday :) Happy Lunar New Year to you and your family, and hope you enjoy your char siu baos!